Difference between revisions of "UWEB:Status/Sunir Shah"
(Fridemar: What about a compromise.) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
([[MeatballWiki]] ...) | ([[MeatballWiki]] ...) | ||
| − | ::{{NotYet}} I'm all for the green, but shapes don't say edit to me. To put my pen where my mouth is, I drew some fountain pen nib shaped icons above to demonstrate icons that speak more readily to me. By the way, I also think some basic usability testing can be done (see below). {{EditIcon|UWEB:Status/Sunir Shah}} | + | ::{{NotYet}} I'm all for the green, but shapes don't say edit to me. To put my pen where my mouth is, I drew some fountain pen nib shaped icons above to demonstrate icons that speak more readily to me. By the way, I also think some basic usability testing can be done (see below). |
| + | |||
| + | Sunir, what about a compromise? Accepting the current proposal and adding your favorite design as a [[CommunityMark]], as described in [[MarkDilley]]s vote. By the way, what do you think about the design at [http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?UniversalWikiEditButton WardsWiki:UniversalWikiEditButton]. In earnest, would you still insist to say, this shape doesn't convey the idea of editing?. [http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?WardCunningham WardCunningham] "just did it" and leaves the refinement to future fine-tuning. As you are a key player as Ward, you would make a lot of wikizens very happy to give your "green light" with '''your highly appreciated YES'''. -- [http://fridemar.com fridemar] | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | {{EditIcon|UWEB:Status/Sunir Shah}} | ||
<noinclude> | <noinclude> | ||
Revision as of 21:02, 3 July 2007
(MeatballWiki ...)
- NotYet I'm all for the green, but shapes don't say edit to me. To put my pen where my mouth is, I drew some fountain pen nib shaped icons above to demonstrate icons that speak more readily to me. By the way, I also think some basic usability testing can be done (see below).
Sunir, what about a compromise? Accepting the current proposal and adding your favorite design as a CommunityMark, as described in MarkDilleys vote. By the way, what do you think about the design at WardsWiki:UniversalWikiEditButton. In earnest, would you still insist to say, this shape doesn't convey the idea of editing?. WardCunningham "just did it" and leaves the refinement to future fine-tuning. As you are a key player as Ward, you would make a lot of wikizens very happy to give your "green light" with your highly appreciated YES. -- fridemar
